The main advantages of a subscription business model are predictable recurring revenue, smoother cash flow, higher customer lifetime value, cash paid in advance, easier planning and a much higher valuation, because buyers value recurring revenue on multiples of revenue rather than profit. The risks are churn, a slower start, heavy users who cost more than they pay, copycats and tightening consumer law.
Key takeaways
- Subscription revenue lets you plan payroll, stock and hiring months ahead instead of living job to job.
- Buyers pay far more for recurring revenue: the book compares a typical small business at 0.67 times revenue with Slack at 26 times projected revenue.
- Churn, slower early revenue and heavy users are the risks that sink subscription businesses.
- Hard-to-cancel subscriptions are now a legal risk, with Australian rules starting 1 July 2027.
We'd put more than $200,000 into my first business, a results-guaranteed marketing agency. And we were still burning through cash.
On paper the agency looked like a success. We were growing fast and winning international clients. But every dollar we earned was a one-time thing. We'd win a few projects and max out our capacity. Then the projects would wrap up, and I'd sit there wondering how I'd pay everyone.
Feast or famine.
In the end I sold the business. Looking back, it was the right call. Kept going, that agency could have cost us our home.
That moment is why I've spent the years since studying subscription businesses, and why I'll be honest with you on this page about the downsides as well as the upsides.
What Are the Advantages of a Subscription Business Model?
1. Predictable revenue
This is the big one. When most of next month's revenue is already locked in, you can cover payroll, plan stock and hire with confidence. You stop living job to job. You sleep at night.
2. Smoother cash flow
Monthly fees arrive whether it's a busy month or a quiet one. Mister Car Wash shows what that does to a weather-dependent business: its Unlimited Wash Club made up 79% of wash sales in 2025, so rainy weeks matter far less. Read the Mister Car Wash case study.
3. Cash in advance
Annual plans paid upfront fund your working capital before you deliver. Kogan held A$11.3 million of membership fees paid in advance at 30 June 2026. That's money in the bank before members buy a thing.
4. Higher customer lifetime value
A customer who buys twice a year becomes one who buys twelve times. Even at a slightly lower price per order, they're usually worth far more over their lifetime.
5. Pricing power
Small, regular price rises on a subscription land as a few dollars a month, not a shock invoice. Xero simplified its plans and raised prices on a fixed date each year, and its average revenue per customer rose 23% in fiscal 2026. See how to raise prices without losing customers.
6. A much more valuable business
This is the advantage most small business owners have never been told about. Here's the table from Chapter 1 of The Subscription Playbook:
| Average small business owner | Slack | |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue | $387k | $867m |
| Sale price | $320,000 on average | $28b to Salesforce |
| Chance of selling | Less than 2% | Acquired |
| Sale price to revenue | 0.67x | 26x projected revenue |
Subscription businesses are usually valued on revenue, not profit, because buyers can see the future in the subscriber base. In the book I estimate that moving to subscription could make the same business five to thirty times as valuable. Read more on recurring revenue multiples.
7. A closer relationship and better data
Subscribers tell you what they use, when and how often. That data helps you improve the product, predict churn and sell more, and it's a big part of building a moat.
Why I'd start with subscription tomorrow
If I were starting a new business tomorrow, recurring subscription revenue with a moat is the model I'd work toward. It's what buyers and investors look for, and it lets you build a business you can work "over" instead of "in." My next business was built on subscription revenue from day one. The contrast with my agency was night and day.
What Are the Disadvantages of the Subscription Model?
Now the part most guides skip. The subscription model isn't infallible. Bad practices and an inability to adapt can sink it.
1. Churn
Every subscription leaks. If customers leave faster than you replace them, growth stalls and the "predictable" revenue isn't. In the book I point out that gyms often sell far more memberships than they can physically support, because so many members stop coming. It works for them. It's not the safest model to copy. Learn the basics in how to reduce churn.
2. A slower start
When you switch, some customers move from big one-off purchases to smaller monthly payments. Revenue can flatten before it climbs. In 2025 Udemy's subscription revenue rose to 72% of the total while total revenue was flat. Read how Udemy made the switch.
3. Heavy users who cost more than they pay
"Unlimited" attracts the customers who'll use the most. Pret's £30-a-month coffee club in the UK drew its heaviest drinkers, and Pret replaced it with a half-price drinks plan in 2024. AI products face the same problem with token costs.
4. Copycats
Putting something on subscription isn't a moat. If a competitor can copy your offer overnight, you'll end up competing on price. Pair subscription with something hard to copy. See how to build a moat.
5. Price-rise fatigue
Customers accept regular rises when value grows. Push too hard, or hide options, and you'll pay for it. In October 2025 the ACCC sued Microsoft, alleging it didn't clearly tell Australian subscribers about a cheaper plan when it raised prices to add AI.
6. Dependence on a feeder product
GoPro's subscription held steady as camera sales fell, but subscriber numbers slipped once fewer new cameras were sold. A subscription attached to a product can't outgrow its feeder forever.
7. Admin and accounting complexity
Recurring billing, failed payments, deferred revenue and GST on every invoice all need systems. Prepaid fees are generally recognized as revenue over time, not when the cash lands. See revenue recognition for subscriptions.
8. Regulation
"Easy to join, hard to leave" now costs real money. In September 2025 Amazon agreed to a $2.5 billion FTC settlement over Prime sign-ups and cancellations. In Australia, new subscription-trap rules commence on 1 July 2027, requiring clear disclosure, notices during the subscription (expected to include reminders before trials end and renewals; the timing is left to regulations) and an easy way to cancel. See Australia's subscription trap laws.
See what subscription would do to your numbers
Model revenue, cash flow and valuation before and after switching with the Subscription vs One-off Profit Calculator.
Worked Example: What Changes When You Switch?
An illustrative cleaning business
Today: about 1,200 cleans a year at an average A$220 (ex-GST), roughly A$264,000 of revenue. Most jobs are booked a week or two out. Some months are packed, others are dead, and revenue next quarter is a guess.
After: the 40 regular clients who account for most of those cleans move to a fortnightly plan at A$190 a clean (a 14% saving). That's 40 × 26 × A$190, about A$197,600 a year, booked in advance. Add the remaining one-off jobs and total revenue dips at first, to about A$233,000, because regulars now pay less per clean. But about three-quarters of the year's revenue is visible today, the team's roster is planned months ahead, and when it's time to sell, a buyer sees contracted recurring revenue instead of a list of past jobs.
Run your own version with the Subscription vs One-off Profit Calculator. For the accountant's view of the cash flow during the switch, read subscriptions and cash flow.
Subscription vs One-off Profit CalculatorSee how switching to subscription changes revenue, cash flow and valuation.Open the free tool →Free Subscription Profit Review
Australian business owners can book a free 30-minute review with a BPAG Accountants adviser. An honest conversation about:
- whether a subscription model could work for your business
- how recurring revenue could cover your fixed costs each month
- how it could lift what your business is worth
No cost, no obligation. General information only until we understand your situation.
Is a Subscription Model Right for Your Business? A Checklist
Tick each one that's true for you:
- Customers buy from you, or need what you sell, more than twice a year.
- You can describe the subscription in one sentence.
- The monthly price covers your cost to deliver at heavy usage, after GST and fees.
- You can offer something competitors can't copy overnight.
- You can keep customers for at least several billing cycles.
- Your offer still works if cancelling takes one click.
- You have, or can set up, recurring billing and reminders.
- You can survive a flat few months while customers switch.
Six or more ticks: subscription is very likely right for you. Pick a model from the eight subscription business models.
Three to five: it can work, but fix the gaps first.
Fewer than three: keep one-off sales as your core and test a small subscription add-on.
What to Do Next
- Work out what share of your revenue is recurring today. Most owners are surprised by how low it is.
- Pick the products or services your customers already buy repeatedly.
- Choose a model and run the numbers, including a realistic churn rate.
- Plan the transition: who moves first, and how you'll fund a flat few months.
- Design the sign-up and cancellation flow to the 2027 Australian rules from day one.
So, here's the question: if your best customer stopped calling tomorrow, how much of next month's revenue would still turn up?
If the answer worries you, it's time to add subscription.
Frequently asked questions
Is a subscription model more profitable than one-off sales?
Not automatically. Subscribers often pay a little less per purchase, so profit per transaction can fall. The gain comes from more transactions per customer, lower marketing cost per sale and a higher business valuation. A subscription is more profitable when customers stay long enough. If they churn within a few months, one-off sales can be better.
Why are investors so keen on subscription businesses?
Because recurring revenue is predictable. A buyer can see next year's revenue in this year's subscriber base, which lowers their risk. That's why subscription businesses are often valued on a multiple of revenue rather than profit, and why Leonard Green agreed to take Mister Car Wash private in 2026 at an enterprise value of about $3.1 billion.
How long does it take to switch a business to subscription?
Most businesses run both models side by side for a while. Expect total revenue to dip or flatten as some one-off buyers move to cheaper monthly plans. Udemy's subscription revenue rose to 72% of the total in 2025 while total revenue stayed flat. Plan your cash flow for a transition period of at least six to twelve months.
Do customers actually like subscriptions?
They like convenience and savings, and dislike feeling trapped. Subscriptions that are easy to pause, change and cancel tend to keep customers longer. The backlash is mostly against hidden terms, surprise renewals and hard cancellations, which is exactly what regulators in the US, UK and Australia are now targeting.
How does subscription revenue appear in my accounts?
If customers pay in advance, you generally recognize the revenue over the period you deliver the service, not when the cash arrives. The unearned part sits on your balance sheet as deferred income. Kogan reported A$11.3 million of membership fees paid in advance at 30 June 2026. Ask your accountant how this affects your reporting and tax.
Get both books free
The Subscription Playbook (ebook + audiobook) and Feed a Starving Crowd, instantly. In Australia? Claim the free hardcover.
Robert Coorey, MBA
Robert is the author of The Subscription Playbook and Feed a Starving Crowd and a Director at BPAG Accountants in Sydney. More about Robert.
Sources
- Car Wash Pro: Mister Car Wash to go private (19 February 2026)
- Kogan.com FY26 results announcement (24 August 2026)
- Udemy Q4 and full-year 2025 results (4 February 2026)
- FTC: $2.5 billion settlement with Amazon (25 September 2025)
- Treasury: Unfair trading practices exposure draft (9 February 2026)
- Rask Media: Xero FY26 result (14 May 2026)
Facts and prices checked 27 October 2026. Spotted something out of date? Tell us.