Under the Australian Consumer Law, services must be provided with due care and skill, be fit for any stated purpose and be delivered within a reasonable time. If a service has a major problem, the customer can cancel and get a refund (less a reasonable amount for work already done properly), or keep the contract at a lower price. For a minor problem, you can generally fix it first. You don't have to refund a change of mind unless your own policy or contract says so. A sign or term saying 'no refunds' under any circumstances is unlawful.
Key takeaways
- Consumer guarantees apply automatically and can't be excluded by your terms.
- A major problem with a service lets the customer cancel and get a refund, less a reasonable amount for work properly done.
- For a minor problem you can generally choose how to fix it, within a reasonable time.
- Change of mind refunds aren't required, but if you offer them you must honour your policy.
- 'No refunds' signs and terms are unlawful. 'No refunds for change of mind' is fine.
In The Subscription Playbook I argue that the easiest way to keep members is to make leaving easy and fair. A clear, generous refund policy is part of that. It also keeps you on the right side of the law, because the consumer guarantees give customers refund rights whatever your terms say.
This guide covers the rules for service businesses: memberships, maintenance plans, clinic packages, software subscriptions and similar.
Who counts as a consumer?
The ACCC says a business can be a consumer too. A purchase is generally covered by the consumer guarantees if it costs less than A$100,000 (including GST), or it's a product or service commonly bought for personal, domestic or household use, whatever the price. That means many B2B services, such as software or a cleaning contract for a small office, can be covered as well.
The guarantees for services
When you supply a service, the Australian Consumer Law guarantees that it will be:
- provided with acceptable care and skill,
- fit for any purpose the customer made known to you, or that you said it would achieve, and
- delivered within a reasonable time, if no time was agreed.
These guarantees apply automatically. You can't contract out of them, and a customer can't sign them away.
Major and minor problems
What you have to do depends on whether the problem is major.
The ACCC describes a major problem as one that would have stopped someone from buying the service if they'd known about it. Examples include a service that is substantially unfit for its common purpose and can't easily be fixed within a reasonable time, or that doesn't meet a specific purpose the customer asked for. It's also treated as major if the service creates an unsafe situation.
Minor problem: you must fix it, for free, and can generally choose how, for example by re-performing the service, within a reasonable time. If you don't fix it, or take too long, the customer may be able to get someone else to fix it and ask you to cover reasonable costs, or cancel and get a refund.
Major problem: the ACCC says the customer can choose to:
- cancel the contract and get a refund. This may not be a full refund, as the customer may need to pay a reasonable amount for work already done as expected, or
- keep the contract, but pay a lower price that takes the problem into account.
Customers may also be entitled to compensation for reasonably foreseeable loss caused by the failure.
What about memberships and subscriptions?
Here's how this usually plays out for a recurring service:
- A gym closes its pool for six months. If the pool was a key part of what members paid for, that may be a major problem for those members. Offering a pause, a lower price or cancellation with a pro-rata refund of prepaid fees is the safe response.
- Software that doesn't work as described. The Australian Consumer Law's definition of goods includes computer software, so for downloaded or installed software the goods guarantees (acceptable quality, matching the description) may apply as well as the services guarantees. For purely cloud-hosted software the position is less settled.
- A member just stops coming. That's change of mind, not a failure. You don't have to refund it, but your contract, your state's industry code (for gyms) and, from 1 July 2027, the new national subscription rules will require you to give subscribers an easy, straightforward way to end the contract (online, if they signed up online).
Our guide to gym membership cancellation rules covers the state fitness codes.
Change of mind
You don't have to give a refund when a customer simply changes their mind. But if you have a change of mind policy, or promise a money-back guarantee, you must honour it. Many subscription businesses choose a short, clearly stated window, because it lowers the risk of signing up.
"No refunds" is unlawful
The ACCC says signs that state "no refunds" are unlawful because they imply a customer can't get a refund in any circumstances, even when there's a major problem. The same goes for terms such as "no refunds on sale items" or "credit notes only". Telling customers they have fewer rights than they do can also be a false or misleading representation.
Wording that is acceptable: "We don't give refunds if you have simply changed your mind."
Unfair terms in a standard form contract, such as a term letting you keep all prepaid fees when you fail to deliver, can also be void under the unfair contract terms rules, and penalties now apply to them.
How to refund
For goods, the ACCC says a refund for a major problem should be the full amount and in the same form as the original payment, unless you both agree otherwise. For services, the refund can reflect a reasonable amount for work already properly done. In practice, for a monthly membership, a pro-rata refund of the unused period is the clearest approach.
Refunds also have tax effects. If you're registered for GST, a refund is generally an adjustment on your BAS, and our guide to prepaid subscription income explains why refund obligations matter for when prepaid income is taxed.
A fair refund policy, in plain English
- What we'll do if something goes wrong (repair, re-do, refund, cancel), in line with the consumer guarantees.
- Whether we offer change of mind refunds, and for how long.
- How to ask for a refund, and how long it takes.
- How prepaid amounts are refunded if you cancel for a major problem.
- A line saying these rights are in addition to your rights under the Australian Consumer Law.
Free Subscription Profit Review
Australian business owners can book a free 30-minute review with a BPAG Accountants adviser. An honest conversation about:
- whether a subscription model could work for your business
- how recurring revenue could cover your fixed costs each month
- how it could lift what your business is worth
No cost, no obligation. General information only until we understand your situation.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to refund a customer who changes their mind?
Generally no. The consumer guarantees don't cover change of mind. But if your policy, contract or a state industry code gives a right to cancel or a refund, you must honour it.
Is a no refunds policy legal in Australia?
A policy or sign saying no refunds in any circumstances is unlawful, because customers are entitled to a remedy when there's a major problem. You can say you don't refund for change of mind.
Do consumer guarantees apply to business customers?
They can. A business is a consumer if the service costs less than A$100,000, or it's commonly bought for personal, domestic or household use.
Can I give a credit note instead of a refund?
For a major problem, the customer can choose a refund. You can offer a credit note, but you can't insist on it when the customer is entitled to a refund.
How much do I refund for a service with a major problem?
The ACCC says it may not be a full refund, because the customer may need to pay a reasonable amount for work already done as expected.
General information only, current as at 9 November 2026. It isn't legal advice. Whether a guarantee applies, and whether a failure is major, depends on the facts. State consumer laws and industry codes (for example fitness codes) can add further rights. Read the ACCC guidance linked below and get advice from a lawyer before relying on this guide.
Talk it through with a BPAG adviser
Free for Australian business owners: a 30-minute Subscription Profit Review on whether a subscription suits your business.
Sources and further reading
- ACCC, Consumer rights and guarantees (updated 28 August 2026)
- ACCC, Repair, replace, refund, cancel
- ACCC, A guide to competition and consumer law for business (PDF)
- Competition and Consumer Act 2010, Schedule 2 (Australian Consumer Law)
Sources checked 9 November 2026. Spotted something out of date? Tell us.
